Cast 55
Mario López
Self - Host (52 episodes)
'Weird Al' Yankovic
Self - Judge (6 episodes)
Ben Stein
Self - Judge (5 episodes)
Vanessa Lengies
Self - Judge (5 episodes)
Will Estes
Self - Judge (4 episodes)
Lori Petty
Self - Judge (4 episodes)
Peter Scolari
Self - Judge (4 episodes)
Richard Jeni
Self - Judge (3 episodes)
Amy Davidson
Self - Judge (3 episodes)
Frankie Muniz
Self - Judge (3 episodes)
Gena Lee Nolin
Self - Judge (3 episodes)
David Brenner
Self - Judge (3 episodes)
Christopher Rich
Self - Judge (3 episodes)
Tempestt Bledsoe
Self - Judge (3 episodes)
Matt Gallant
Self - Judge (2 episodes)
Carol Leifer
Self - Judge (2 episodes)
Kelly Packard
Self - Judge (2 episodes)
Mackenzie Phillips
Self - Judge (2 episodes)
Meshach Taylor
Self - Judge (2 episodes)
John Kricfalusi
Self - Judge (2 episodes)
Melissa Peterman
Self - Judge (2 episodes)
George Wallace
Self - Judge (2 episodes)
Maria Menounos
Self - Judge (2 episodes)
French Stewart
Self - Judge (2 episodes)
Antonio Sabàto, Jr.
Self - Judge (2 episodes)
Ken Howard
Self - Judge (2 episodes)
Fred Willard
Self - Judge (2 episodes)
Josh Meyers
Self - Judge (2 episodes)
Melissa Rivers
Self - Judge (2 episodes)
Lauren Tom
Self - Judge (1 episode)
Ringo Starr
Self - Judge (1 episode)
Danny Bonaduce
Self - Judge (1 episode)
Brett Butler
Self - Judge (1 episode)
Dom DeLuise
Self - Judge (1 episode)
R. Lee Ermey
Self - Judge (1 episode)
Debra Wilson
Self - Judge (1 episode)
Tim Curry
Self - Judge (1 episode)
Wayne Knight
Self - Judge (1 episode)
Karri Turner
Celebrity Judge #2 (self) (1 episode)
Rowan Atkinson
Self - Judge (1 episode)
Gilbert Gottfried
Self - Judge (1 episode)
Adam West
Self - Judge (1 episode)
Gabrielle Carteris
Self - Judge (1 episode)
Brie Larson
Self - Judge (1 episode)
Butch Hartman
Self - Judge (1 episode)
Danny Cooksey
Self - Judge (1 episode)
Luke Perry
Self - Judge (1 episode)
Lindsay Wagner
Self - Judge (1 episode)
Jay Leno
Self - Judge (1 episode)
Rosa Blasi
Self - Judge (1 episode)
Billy West
Self - Judge (1 episode)
Brad Pitt
Self - Judge (1 episode)
Sylvester Stallone
Self - Judge (1 episode)
Adam Sandler
Self - Judge (1 episode)
Kaley Cuoco
Self - Judge (1 episode)